Magnolia Grill

11/09/09

Honestly disappointed

by funnyornot at Citysearch

So many people brag about this restaurant so I finally went for a try. Forgive my ignorance: reservation on the day is too late. Later I was told I should reserve 3 weeks in advance. Okay, my bad, but I was looking forward to the food even more!

We waited 45 minutes for our appetizer. Lots of dishes ran out by the time we ordered but magically became available when we left. Appetizers and entrees were decent; I've had much better ones with much lower cost. The only plus I'd give for Magnolia Grill is its desserts: the chocolate tart was absolutely superb.

Waiting staff were friendly and professional, but An's is better. VERY slow service and honestly the food was not worth the wait.

• Pros: Dessert
• Cons: Price and service

07/31/09

Disappointing

by Pharmalady at Citysearch

We went to the Magnolia grill for our wedding anniversary, I have been there in the past and found the food to be delicious, and therefore we picked the place. We ordered the fresh tomato salad which was wonderful, but it all went downhill from there. The crusted grouper I ordered was overcooked, the crust a bit burnt and the fish dry, I complained to the waitress that it tasted bad, she talked to the manager and came back with, and I quote: “we can get you something else, but you will have to pay for both dishes. . .”

We also ordered the “French toast brulle” apparently they must have been short staffed in the kitchen that day, as this was a bit singed as well. The peach ice cream that went with it was delicious though.

I would recommend Nana’s in Durham instead, if you are celebrating a special occasion and do not want to ruin it with “overcooked arrogance”.

• Pros: delicious salad and ice-cream
• Cons: overcooked main course

06/03/09

Big fish in a little snobby pond

by LMar at Citysearch

In town for business? Save yourself the hassle if you're visiting Raleigh and spend your money where it is appreciated. This is just a big fish in a tiny pond. Servers are rude and unaccommodating.

When our 9 month pregnant guest asked for a menu modification, for obvious health purposes, the server simply answered, "no." I understand that menu changes from customers are annoying, however, so are unmannerly restaurants and servers (it comes from above).

We will not go back because of the service. Food was incredible.

If you can tolerate the pretentious service then bon appetit, however, I think your money is better spent elsewhere.

• Pros: Incredible food and menu
• Cons: snobby service